Wednesday, January 31, 2007

The exploitation of suffering...

In Greece we are a nation I think that panic easily over health issues and often exaggerate. In psychological studies Greek s often demonstrate high levels of health anxiety and general worries over their health. There are also people that live through TV and they adopt as an established truth what they generally listen through this little box.

What occurred lately was a parade of doctors and people who have been cured from cancer on TV shows. They were suggesting that drinking the juice that the leaves of an olive tree produce could combat potentially cancer. The doctors were unsure as this assumption is not scientifically tested however they were on the shows along with ex-cancer patients and this for a simple person translates as a possibility for a cure!

When you bring people on a show that claim that they have been cured they are going to direct their hopes on this new cure and ignore that this is just an assumption of some TV doctors and is not something that is embraced by the medical community. Television has a great influence on people and can lead to the manipulation of the masses quite easily. People started drinking this juice and some were admitted to hospital with intestinal pains. There were also people who sold leaves and prepared this recipe for people and not without a price.

I was talking to an older friend about this incident and he told me that when he was young there was a similar incidence of mass hysteria. Someone from Kamatero was claiming that he had access to water that could cure cancer. In the end of course he was imprisoned for fraud but on the court many people appeared that believed that they were cured from cancer and supported him wholehearted.

There are people who suffer from serious and chronic illness like cancer and desperately seek for cure. Encouraging people to drink daily the juice of olive leaves is giving false hope to the patients. Maybe the leaves are beneficial but there has not been any research that proves that. Maybe the leaves are beneficial but can they be beneficial alone? The cure of the disease relies on interplay of different factors. It depends on the biology of the individual, on the psychological state, on his/her quality of life and the medical treatment that this person receives. Therefore, my impression is that there can‘t be an only cure. There can only be a ground for a further manipulation and degradation of the sufferers. People who want to benefit are aware that when a person suffers is ready to believe in absolutely anything.

Stormrider has written a beautiful article on his opinion over the olives leaves incident and particularly on the responsibility of the doctors link)

(image by wrenda)

9 comments:

AC Stranger said...

Υποκλινομαι στον εφευρετη του οπου 'φραπελια'

Stormrider said...

the most annoying thing is that people misunderstand the idea of "beneficial". For example drinking green tea IS beneficial, it contains lots of anti-cancer ingredients. But by no means can it actually CURE CANCER or prevent it if you lead a non-healthy life, smoking and eating junk food.

Pixie said...

@Storm
I know what you mean!Good nutrition,exercise,reduction of stress are beneficial.And even if there was a pill you could take to cure it it would not be enough as you said it requires a healthy lifestyle.What do you think about the story in Kamatero?We are easily manipulated and influenced in this country.Αlso placebo pills work well here in Greece.It's only natural I don't blame people as they need to believe but for the rest...

Stormrider said...

@pixie
I 've just head the Kamatero story, but I don't know details. I can guess that it doesn't differ much from the matter we are dealing now...

Anastasia Konstantakatou said...

This is all very interesting what you are describing here pixie and I will agree to the extent my empirical understanding allows me, given i have not studied or read psychological reports and papers.

Being away from Greece, I am left puzzled: what on earth is going on with the olive trees??? I keep reading beats and pieces all over...

Να έχετε μια όμορφη μέρα!

Pixie said...

@Anastasia
well you don't miss anything sweety!There was a spread of information by two TV shows that the juice of olive leaves can cure cancer. So many people started drinking either to cure cancer or to prevent it.As a result of this incidence people started to gain money by selling leaves,some that drunk the juice had intestinal pains and some stopped their cancer medication.All these occur in a country that panicks constantly over their health!

Vic Vega said...

Television mass control is not something new. I believe that any TV show that supported olive leaves can cure cancer should be punished by the law. The same goes for any doctor on these shows who did not say otherwise. As for those who believed them what can I say. Victims are everywhere waiting to be tricked.

Dawkinson said...

Πολύ πιο παλιά, γύρω στο 70 δεν ήταν το νερό του Καματερού κάτι πολύ χειρότερο, που οδήγησε σε αντίστοιχη υστερία και μαζικό παραλλήρημα; Η βιομηχανία της απόγνωσης είναι από τα πιο καννιβαλιστικά demos της ανθρώπινης φύσης.

Anonymous said...

Θα περάσει και αυτή η μόδα-υστερία,όπως και οι προηγούμενες!